A fair account of what kits are

Hardware-store kits (Rust-Oleum Tub & Tile and similar) are typically a two-part epoxy you roll or brush over the tub after cleaning and sanding it yourself. Cost is usually under $100, and plenty of handy homeowners get a visibly better-looking tub out of a weekend's careful work. We won't pretend otherwise — for a rental about to be renovated anyway, or a tub you just need presentable for a year, a carefully applied kit can be a rational choice.

Where kits fall short — and it's chemistry, not skill

  • Preparation. Professional refinishing uses chemical surface treatments (and full stripping of any previous coating) that aren't available in consumer kits. Adhesion is everything in this trade, and adhesion is made in prep.
  • Materials. Consumer epoxies are formulated to be safe for untrained users in unventilated bathrooms — which caps their performance. Professional coatings are more durable and UV-resistant, and require the ventilation equipment and training we bring.
  • Application. Rolled and brushed coatings show lap marks, bubbles, and drips, and build an uneven film. Sprayed application lays down the smooth, glossy, uniform surface people mean when they say "looks brand new."
  • Lifespan. The common DIY pattern is a good-looking result that yellows, dulls, or starts peeling at the drain and soap-dish edges within months to a couple of years. A professional job in Calgary runs $600–$900 and is warrantied in writing for 5 years against spontaneous peeling, lifting, and cracking.

The math over time

A $75 kit that lasts 18 months costs about $50 a year and leaves you doing the work. A $600–$900 professional refinish lasting 7–10 years costs $60–$130 a year, warrantied, sprayed smooth, with repairs to chips and cracks done properly before coating. If you plan to be in the home for more than a couple of years, the professional job is cheaper per year — and it's the one that looks factory-finished.

If your DIY job has already failed

You're not stuck, and you're not the first. The failed coating is stripped off completely, the surface is re-prepared, and the tub is refinished properly. Stripping adds some cost over a first-time refinish — nobody can bond a warrantied coating to someone else's peeling epoxy — but the result is the same like-new tub. Call 403 630 6534 and describe (or email photos of) what's on the tub now; we'll give you an honest assessment.