The simple math
A properly refinished tub can reasonably be expected to last 7 to 10 years with normal use and sensible care. At $600–$900, that's roughly $60–$130 per year for a smooth, glossy surface that looks and feels new. A replacement tub costs $3,000–$5,000 or more once you count demolition, the new tub, plumbing adjustments, and retiling the surround — plus several days of a torn-apart bathroom.
When refinishing is clearly worth it
- The surface is worn, dull, stained, or won't come clean no matter what you use.
- There are chips, scratches, or surface rust — these are repaired during preparation, before coating.
- The colour is dated (aged off-white, harvest gold, avocado green) and you want it modern.
- The tub itself — cast iron, steel, acrylic, or fiberglass — is structurally sound. Older cast iron in particular is often in excellent shape; it's only the porcelain surface that wears.
- You're preparing a home for sale, or turning over a rental unit, and need the bathroom presentable in days, not weeks.
When it's honestly not worth it
If the tub body itself has severe structural damage, replacement genuinely makes more sense — refinishing restores surfaces, it doesn't rebuild tubs. Two nuances worth knowing:
- A cracked, flexing fiberglass floor is not a lost cause. That specific problem has a permanent fix called a tub inlay, which rebuilds the floor without removing the tub.
- If you're unsure, ask. We've refinished tubs in Calgary since 2002, and if replacement is the right call for your tub, we'll say so before you spend anything. Quotes are free.
Set expectations honestly
One thing many refinishing companies won't tell you: a refinished coating is not as tough as the original factory porcelain, which was baked on at the foundry under high heat. A refinished surface is sprayed and chemically cured on site. Both look great and both perform well — but the refinished surface asks slightly more of you: gentle non-abrasive cleaners, no suction-cup bath mats, and prompt repair of any chips. Treat it reasonably and 7–10 good years is a realistic expectation, backed by our written 5-year residential warranty against spontaneous peeling, lifting, and cracking.