The two products, side by side
| Tub inlay | Tub liner | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Fiberglass-reinforced panel (FRP) fitted to the tub floor | Full acrylic shell moulded over the entire tub |
| What it fixes | Cracked, soft, flexing, or leaking tub floors — a structural problem | Covers the whole tub's appearance |
| Coverage | The damaged floor area only | Floor, walls, and rim |
| Installation | Measured, fitted, and permanently bonded on site; 1–2 visits | Custom-fabricated off site (often weeks of lead time), then fitted over the tub |
| Known drawback | Addresses the floor only — cosmetic wear elsewhere is a separate (refinishing) job | If the shell isn't perfectly sealed, water can become trapped between liner and tub |
Why the confusion exists
Both products go over an existing tub without removing it, so the names get used interchangeably online — but they solve different problems. If your issue is a cracked or flexing floor, a liner is more product than you need. If your issue is the whole tub's worn appearance, the honest comparison isn't inlay vs. liner at all — it's liner vs. refinishing, where refinishing restores the tub's own surface for $600–$900 with nothing layered over it to trap water.
Where we stand
Blackstone supplies and installs tub inlays — and for tubs whose whole surface is worn, we refinish. We don't install liners, and that's a deliberate choice: between refinishing for cosmetics and inlays for structural floor problems, we can solve the same situations without a liner's water-trapping risk or fabrication wait. A floor inlay can also be combined with refinishing the rest of the tub for a complete restoration in the same project.
Not sure which problem you have?
Simple test: does the floor flex, feel soft, or show cracks that came back after repair? That's structural — inlay territory. Is the surface dull, stained, or chipped but solid underfoot? That's cosmetic — refinishing. Call 403 630 6534 or email photos and we'll tell you which applies, honestly, before you spend anything.