The two products, side by side

Tub inlayTub liner
What it isFiberglass-reinforced panel (FRP) fitted to the tub floorFull acrylic shell moulded over the entire tub
What it fixesCracked, soft, flexing, or leaking tub floors — a structural problemCovers the whole tub's appearance
CoverageThe damaged floor area onlyFloor, walls, and rim
InstallationMeasured, fitted, and permanently bonded on site; 1–2 visitsCustom-fabricated off site (often weeks of lead time), then fitted over the tub
Known drawbackAddresses the floor only — cosmetic wear elsewhere is a separate (refinishing) jobIf the shell isn't perfectly sealed, water can become trapped between liner and tub

Why the confusion exists

Both products go over an existing tub without removing it, so the names get used interchangeably online — but they solve different problems. If your issue is a cracked or flexing floor, a liner is more product than you need. If your issue is the whole tub's worn appearance, the honest comparison isn't inlay vs. liner at all — it's liner vs. refinishing, where refinishing restores the tub's own surface for $600–$900 with nothing layered over it to trap water.

Where we stand

Blackstone supplies and installs tub inlays — and for tubs whose whole surface is worn, we refinish. We don't install liners, and that's a deliberate choice: between refinishing for cosmetics and inlays for structural floor problems, we can solve the same situations without a liner's water-trapping risk or fabrication wait. A floor inlay can also be combined with refinishing the rest of the tub for a complete restoration in the same project.

Not sure which problem you have?

Simple test: does the floor flex, feel soft, or show cracks that came back after repair? That's structural — inlay territory. Is the surface dull, stained, or chipped but solid underfoot? That's cosmetic — refinishing. Call 403 630 6534 or email photos and we'll tell you which applies, honestly, before you spend anything.