In October 2026 we got a call from a Cochrane customer whose fiberglass shower had already been repaired once before. The old repair had failed, and they wanted to know why.

Finding the Real Problem

We started by inspecting the shower floor and drilling a few small holes into it. It quickly became clear that there was almost no support under the floor. The previous repair technician had not checked for support issues, and that is why the repair failed.

To find out how deep the hollow area went, we slid a 6 inch metal rod into one of the holes. It still did not hit bottom. Once we cut out a large section of the floor, we found there was no subfloor under half of the shower base, and water had been leaking onto the kitchen ceiling below.

Fiberglass shower floor in Cochrane with a section cut out, showing patched wood and open gaps underneath
Opening up the floor. The section we cut out sits at the top of the photo, and underneath is patchwork wood with open gaps.

Rebuilding the Support

The next challenge was to build enough backing between the floor joists to install a new section of plywood subfloor. With solid support back in place, we:

  • Reinstalled the section of fiberglass we had cut out
  • Laid down two layers of heavy fiberglass matting
  • Finished off the rest of the bodywork
  • Refinished the shower floor
New wood backing installed between floor joists around the shower drain
New backing between the joists, around the drain.
Open areas under the shower floor filled in with new wood
Filling in the open areas to build a solid base.
New plywood subfloor screwed down under the shower floor opening
New plywood subfloor in place, ready for the fiberglass.

The Result

The customer now has a solid floor and a shower they can use with confidence. There are no more leaks, and there is no chance of a foot going through the shower floor, so a real safety hazard is gone.

Finished white fiberglass corner shower floor after repair and refinishing
The finished shower floor, solid underfoot and refinished.

The lesson here is simple: a crack in a fiberglass floor is often a sign of what is happening underneath. If the support problem is not fixed, the crack will come back no matter how good the surface repair looks. You can read more about this kind of work on our fiberglass tub and shower repair page.

Quick Answers

Why does a fiberglass shower floor feel soft or spongy?

A fiberglass shower floor needs solid support underneath it. When that support is missing or has given way, the floor flexes every time you step on it, and that is the soft, spongy feeling. On this Cochrane job there was no subfloor at all under half of the shower base.

Why do fiberglass shower floor repairs fail?

Most often because the repair only fixes the surface. If nobody checks what is under the floor, it keeps flexing and the crack or soft spot comes back. That is exactly what happened with the earlier repair on this shower.

Can a soft or cracked fiberglass shower floor be fixed without replacing the shower?

In many cases, yes. On this job we rebuilt the support from underneath, reinstalled the original fiberglass with two layers of heavy matting, and refinished the floor. The shower base stayed in place, with no tear-out.

Is a soft shower floor a safety problem?

It can be. A floor with no support underneath can eventually give way under a person's weight, and the cracks that come with it let water leak through. In this home, water had already been leaking onto the kitchen ceiling below.

Is Your Tub or Shower Floor Soft or Cracked?

Do you, or someone you know, have a tub or shower floor that feels soft and spongy, or a tub with long cracks running from the front to the back? Blackstone Tub Refinishers can help. Give us a call at 403 630 6534 or email us at [email protected].